Web designer Frank Jonen has taken extreme action against his late-paying client, San Francisco-based gym chain Fitness SF.
Mr Jonen's web design firm has been working on the new Fitness SF website and brand identity for over six months; but he ultimately took the decision to replace their homepage with a simple text statement.
The text explained that Fitness SF have paid nothing beyond a "barren advance", ignoring invoices and refusing to cover costs incurred on rush fees, weekend working and overtime.
In forum posts linked from his statement, Mr Jonen outlined some of those extra costs - such as a highly detailed 3D interpretation of the Fitness SF logo.
"That was kind of a raw one," he writes on Luxology. "Site launch, lots of client-side changes (not to mention my own), just a lot of time constraints to juggle. Completion time about 10 days on and off during conception time."
He adds that the digital design process, with software that occasionally crashes during rendering, is "like making out with a supermodel and she keeps passing out - end of the day, you still made out with a supermodel".
Sadly, Fitness SF did not share Mr Jonen's passion for his work, and after refusing to pay for half a year of work carried out and delivered to them, they later backtracked, removing some elements from the website, but failing to replace fundamental design elements like the site's Cascading Style Sheet (CSS), which dictates things like the colour scheme, fonts used and certain visual and layout parameters.
Content continues below
Many small businesses are caught out when clients refuse to pay their invoices. For a small startup, a handful of unpaid invoices can make the difference between a healthy bank balance and a full-on…
Late payments are a pain for all of us, clapping the irons on our cashflow, disrupting client relationships and generally causing a world of stress until they're resolved either directly or through…
The lessons of the 2008 banking crisis seemed obvious. Economic growth built on the shaky foundations of unsustainable debt was nothing more than a house of cards ready to come crashing down.The…
Following on from part one "Going Dutch: Contractor Debt Recovery in the Netherlands" we speak to Alex Tucker, the contractor who found himself at loggerheads with the Dutch agency and find out more…
The Opposing View
As always, there are two sides to every story, and after Fitness SF's website was restored and Mr Jonen's statement removed, the chain took to their Tumblr account to publish a riposte.
Entitled On The Way To Our Website, this accuses Mr Jonen of hacking and theft of the Fitness SF domain name.
It claims that the "barren advance" to which he refers amounted to $5,000, and that the 10-week deadline outlined in his initial proposal was breached by Mr Jonen.
"He missed numerous deadlines, including our brand launch in September," Fitness SF state, adding that Mr Jonen subsequently passed the project voluntarily to a different design firm for completion.
"Frank is attempting to portray himself as the victim ... as he attempts to get paid for work he did not complete," the fitness firm adds.
This is perhaps the most recognisable element of the entire dispute: a client who, after missed deadlines and incomplete work, do not wish to pay their designer, pitted against a designer who could equally cite creative differences as the cause of the delays, and who would undoubtedly argue that payment should be made, at least in part, for the work carried out before the handover.
Chasing Overseas Clients
Chasing Fitness SF for payment could be difficult for Mr Jonen as an individual - as he notes, many small businesses and freelancers face non-payment from "larger corporations who can afford to starve them out".
But he adds: "An injury to one is an injury to all of us," a statement that is not only true of the freelance, small-business and design communities, but of all companies everywhere whose supply chains are interlinked, and who contribute towards the same national economies.
In her recent guest post for Safe Collections, entitled How to Chase Late Payments from Overseas Clients, freelance blogger Claire Broadley noted the different rules that apply within the EU and beyond.
Within the EU, the so-called Late Payments Directive is about to take effect, and makes it theoretically much easier to apply additional fees and charges to overdue invoices in any EU member state.
Further afield, recovering debts can be tricky, but Safe Collections have a good success rate when working internationally, including with debtors based in the US.
We work with international agents, who are able to handle the parts of the case that must be dealt with in the US, while we coordinate the UK-based parts of the process.
Together, this gives you the best possible chance of receiving your funds - even if the client is based in a different country to you.
Whilst we understand why Frank felt forced into taking drastic action, taking a client website offline can, in our experience, negatively impact on your chances for recovery. Unless your contract or terms of business explicitly state your company will suspend hosting of a site for non-payment, you could find yourself fighting an avoidable counter-claim and possibly a computer misuse charge.
Over 150 Years Of Industry Experience
Our modest but highly skilled team has a combined total of over 150 years of experience in commercial credit management and B2B debt collection. From independent IT contractors to major film and TV publishers, Safe Collections has the knowledge and experience you need to get paid quickly and cost effectively.