Many small to medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) across the UK are effectively being forced to loan money to large firms interest-free, according to the Federation of Small Businesses.
In one of a pair of landmark reports issued since the beginning of the year, the FSB warns that late payments and unreasonable renegotiation of payment terms is taking money out of the hands of SMEs, and allowing it to languish for longer in the accounts of the nation's largest corporations.
At a time when bank finance is hard to come by, this is effectively transforming SMEs into an army of interest-free lenders, with repercussions felt throughout the supply chain.
Who is paying late?
The FSB found that 51% of its members were paid late by at least one large organisation in the past 12 months, while many other big brands demand payment terms of up to 120 days, making SME suppliers wait four months for even a 'prompt' payment.
This echoes concerns raised by Lord Digby Jones in November, when he told the BBC that:
"the company at the top is basically borrowing off the small business rather than borrowing off the bank".
John Allan, national chairman of the FSB, makes the same observation:
"Small businesses simply can't be expected to lend interest-free to their large customers, which is in effect what extended payment terms and late payments results in."
How much do they owe?
In the second of the major reports to be published in early 2014 so far, the Confederation of British Industry puts a price on late payment in the UK.
According to the CBI, the average business is now owed £31,000, and the total overdue bill is more than £30 billion.
Content continues below
So you have just won a new client. You aced the bidding process, the initial project meetings went well and the money is good. You can’t wait to get started, when out of the blue you get the…
Vertu Corporation Limited, the well-known British manufacturer of luxury smartphones, has finally filed for insolvency after being passed between owners since 2012. The company was known for its…
New York publishing house Condé Nast has reportedly come up with a novel solution to the tricky issue of ensuring its contributors get paid on time. As reported here, the magazine empire behind…
It feels like we have been here before somehow. Lots of well-meaning words, a tough-sounding stance… and then what? Rinse and repeat. The latest announcement from the government on the subject of…
Matthew Fell, CBI director for competitive markets, says:
"Most companies agree and stick to fair payment terms, but we need to create a culture of prompt payment in all businesses."
What problems does this cause?
Returning to the FSB report, it is clear that delayed payments - whether due to being overdue, or due to unfairly lengthened payment terms - are causing problems not just for SMEs, but throughout supply chains.
More than a third (34%) have seen their profitability hit by late payments, and 29% have been unable to grow their business as much as if they had had the funds available.
Significantly, almost a third (32%) have had to pay their own suppliers late, amplifying the effect along the supply chain - for example, if £1,000 is owed by a large company to an SME supplier, and that SME in turn cannot pay a £1,000 bill to a supplier of their own, the total debt in the system is £2,000.
Because of this, any move towards prompter payments by a big brand could have a disproportionately positive ripple effect for the economy as a whole - just as any move away from prompt payment can be disproportionately negative.
The ball is in the court of the big businesses, however; and with SMEs unlikely to name and shame the large corporations, for fear of losing their business, it seems only a commitment to ethical practices at board level, or a further tightening of UK payment legislation, will change the fortunes of British supply chains in general.
Over 150 Years Of Industry Experience
Our modest but highly skilled team has a combined total of over 150 years of experience in commercial credit management and B2B debt collection. From independent IT contractors to major film and TV publishers, Safe Collections has the knowledge and experience you need to get paid quickly and cost effectively.