1000 characters left

Anonymous “testimonials” aren’t worth the paper they are written on

Rate this item
(1 Vote)

Now we know that Debt Collection and Debt Recovery don’t have the best reputation in business markets, this is one of the reasons we take pride in displaying a small selection of the hundreds of client testimonials we have received over the years on our main site.

Nothing usual in that you may be thinking, but have you noticed that unlike some other agencies all of our references are clearly attributable to both a named company and an individual within that company?


So why do we do this?  Well the answer is simple, as with all of our business dealings we pride ourselves on our honesty and transparency.  We don’t believe any company in any industry should use anonymous or unnamed testimonials.

Lets take a look at a few examples, first off one of the testimonials from a long standing client available on our Testimonials page.

In the 20 plus years that I have dealt with Safe Collections, whilst working at The Creative Haus and my previous employers, Imagehaus and AGL, I have always found their service to be professional, accurate and with a fast response.

I have used them for credit checks and to secure money on bad debt and they have always succeeded and totally taken the strain of dealing with these difficult situations in their stride.

I can recommend them whole heartedly for their professional, friendly and fast service.

Liz Smythson - Director

The CreativeHaus LtdNow everyone can clearly see both the name of the individual and also the name of the company that supplied the testimonial.  This gives complete clarity and transparency as anyone can independently research both the individual and the company involved.  Easy.

Easy-peasy, lemon-squeezy

Now lets have a look at some other companies shall we?  For this example we have used businesses in our own industry (who shall remain nameless).

The first site we visited had a very nice looking testimonials page, with what appeared to be pictures of smiling happy customers.  Comments included:

Steve Cooper Finance Director - Investment Firm

"We've used other means of trying to collect our debts and wecan categorically state that ThisCo have been by far the most impressive."

Lucy Dawson Senior Credit Controller - UK Tyre Manuf.

"ThisCo came highly recommended to us. 2 years on and we are the ones now doing the recommending. First class service with first class results." So what is the problem?  Well first of all, whilst we have an individual attributed to the comment, the ecstatically happy client company have declined to be named.

This begs the question of who exactly gives a glowing testimonial, but refuses to put their name on it?

If that wasn’t enough a quick image search using TinEye shows that far from being images of happy customers, these images are in fact widely used stock commercial images.

So we have an un-attributable testimonial, coupled with stock photos.  This is the company equivalent of:

It’s a great service, I use it all the time.

Dave Smith

The Pub, last night.In fact on this site, none of the dozen or so testimonials on our first test subject have any real information in them at all.

Just one bad apple?

Unfortunately that doesn’t appear to be the case…  Our next subject trades under a different name to our previous example and is ostensibly an entirely different company.

But strangely Lucy Dawson appears to have changed her name somewhere along the way as this company has exactly the same testimonial!

"ThisCo came highly recommended to us. 2 years on and we are the ones now doing the recommending. First class service with first class results."

Emma Thompson

Senior Credit Controller - UK Tyre Manufacturer Now, we can’t say for certain that Lucy Dawson wasn’t replaced by Emma Thompson at this particular UK Tyre Manufacturer. Similarly we can’t say for certain that Emma Thompson did not in fact just recycle her colleague’s earlier (and now outdated) testimonial.

But what we can say is that again the image of that happy smiling customer, is in fact, yet another stock photo.

Now call us old fashioned, but we do not think that re-using the same testimonial for a different company is ethical or helpful and the ASA would appear to support us.  If you have a look over at the Committee of Advertising Practice page hereit clearly states:

Endorsements and Testimonials

3.45        Marketers must hold documentary evidence that a testimonial or endorsement used in a marketing communication is genuine, unless it is obviously fictitious, and hold contact details for the person who, or organisation that, gives it. So next time you see a testimonial on a website that doesn’t ring true, why not ask the company in question for the contact information on the person or company who supplied the testimonial.

If the company in question can’t or won’t supply the details, then you may want to consider making a complaint to the ASA and carefully consider if you want to do business with them at all.

Update:  Lucy Dawson and Emma Thompson sure do get around, we have now found exactly the same now completely un-named testimonials on a site operating from Texas in the USA!  Marketing. Fail.

Original Image from Zigazou76

Get in touch

Phone  +44 (0)8454 500962


Email  info@safe-collections.com


at symbol  @Safe_Collects

Most Popular

Prev Next

Synthite Chemicals Ltd - B2B Fraud Alert - Updated

09-05-2013 Adam Home - avatar Adam Home

Company impersonation fraud is big business these days as scammers, fraudsters and criminals increasingly realize the advantages this type of fraud has over the more "traditional" types of fraud that...

Read more

Croydon conman who fooled Harrods with a dud cheque

25-07-2013 Adam Home - avatar Adam Home

Have you heard the one about the Croydon conman who paid for his shopping in Harrods with a £245,000 dud cheque? It's no joke - 49-year-old Philip Buffett of Fairfield Road...

Read more

A (Freelance) Christmas Carol - #Scroogeclient

05-12-2012 Adam Home - avatar Adam Home

A Christmas Collection The payment was late: to begin with. There is no doubt whatever about that. This must be distinctly understood, or nothing wonderful can come of this story I...

Read more

Counting the financial cost of poor credit control

28-11-2013 Adam Home - avatar Adam Home

The world of credit control brings to mind the infamous Donald Rumsfeld quote: "There are known knowns; there are things we know that we know. There are known unknowns; that is...

Read more

How to Chase Late Payments From Overseas Clients

13-02-2013 Adam Home - avatar Adam Home

Many small businesses are caught out when clients refuse to pay their invoices. For a small startup, a handful of unpaid invoices can make the difference between a healthy bank...

Read more

Hitting the Headlines: Safe Collections in the Guardian

16-05-2014 Adam Home - avatar Adam Home

If you're a Guardian reader, you may have seen Safe Collections' collections and partnerships manager Adam Home quoted in a Guardian Professional article on May 12th. Tim Aldred's piece looked at...

Read more

Another ‘Cowboy’ Debt Collection Company Liquidated

17-04-2013 Adam Home - avatar Adam Home

As a fully licensed debt collection company that has been incorporated since 1984, we have a long history in providing advice on how to choose an ethical and trustworthy debt...

Read more

How to Chase an Overdue Invoice

28-03-2014 Adam Home - avatar Adam Home

Unless you have the luxury of an in-house credit controller - which is something even some larger firms can't afford - you might be tempted to take a head-in-the-sand approach...

Read more

Local authorities urged to 'manage debt collection more responsibly'

23-08-2013 Adam Home - avatar Adam Home

Local authorities have been urged to manage their debt collection processes more responsibly, in order to cut down on the 1.8 million instances each year in which bailiffs are hired...

Read more

HFO CAPITAL, HFO Services and Roxburghe UK Ltd unfit says OFT

06-02-2014 Adam Home - avatar Adam Home

The OFT has refused to renew the consumer credit licences of debt purchaser HFO Capital Limited, and two associated debt collectors, HFO Services Limited and Roxburghe (UK) Limited.

Read more

Most Recent

Prev Next

Save 50% or more on Export Credit Reports

14-11-2014 Adam Home - avatar Adam Home

When you're supplying a company overseas, Export Credit Reports are an essential means of checking the creditworthiness of any new client before allowing them to run up a debt. Chasing debts...

Read more

Fraudulent Emergency Services Advertising Company Wound Up

06-11-2014 Adam Home - avatar Adam Home

A company called "The Emergency Services (Media Dept) Limited" that falsely claimed to be linked to the emergency services in an attempt to convince small businesses in to placing adverts...

Read more

Unpaid Invoice Spammers Insidious New Tactic

22-10-2014 Adam Home - avatar Adam Home

We have previously covered how unpaid invoice spammers target credit control failures using an archaic .arj file to spread malicious software, but a new and considerably more dangerous threat has...

Read more

Zombie businesses 'try to run before they can walk'

22-10-2014 Adam Home - avatar Adam Home

  The zombie apocalypse could be coming sooner than you think, with R3, the Association of Business Recovery Professionals, warning that an even greater number of companies are now showing the...

Read more

Chocolatier threatens Tesco with winding-up petition over Unpaid Invoice

18-10-2014 Adam Home - avatar Adam Home

A dairy-free chocolatier was forced to threaten supermarket giant Tesco with a winding-up petition after they failed to pay for part of their order for five months - leaving him...

Read more

Half of unpaid invoices become bad debts in the Americas

15-10-2014 Adam Home - avatar Adam Home

If you deal with customers in the Americas - including not just the USA, but also Canada, Mexico and Brazil - you should be aware of the increased likelihood of...

Read more

'Overdue invoice' spammers target credit control failures

07-10-2014 Adam Home - avatar Adam Home

Credit control failures are a worry at the best of times, and none of us want to be left with overdue invoices to chase - or with unpaid invoices of...

Read more

Indy or Bust: Scottish Referendum ramifications for rUK

16-09-2014 Adam Home - avatar Adam Home

The Scottish Question is about to be answered, and whether the majority vote Yes or No, changes are on the horizon for the Scottish economy and for those of us...

Read more

How to agree effective credit terms

09-09-2014 Adam Home - avatar Adam Home

Whether you're in business on your own, or part of a company, it's essential to protect your income - and one of the greatest areas of risk is when you...

Read more

How to manage export clients

27-08-2014 Adam Home - avatar Adam Home

When working with clients who are based overseas, there are several things you should take into account - ideally, from the moment you begin working for them, rather than later...

Read more

Blog - Search

Spotlight: USA Debt Collection

USA Debt Recovery - Statute of Limitations by State

USA Debt Recovery - Statute of Limitations by State

Continuing our series of articles on debt collection in the USA, this article covers the S...

Read more

Spotlight: Scams & Tricks

Synthite Chemicals Ltd - B2B Fraud Alert - Updated

Synthite Chemicals Ltd - B2B Fraud Alert - Updated

Company impersonation fraud is big business these days as scammers, fraudsters and crimina...

Read more

Spotlight: Debt Collection

'Softly softly' approach to late payments lacks bite

'Softly softly' approach to late payments lacks bite

The government's ongoing pledge to help small businesses keep their cashflow looking healt...

Read more

Spotlight: Credit Control

How to credit check a new customer (for free!)

How to credit check a new customer (for free!)

Most people have heard of credit checks - even if what you immediately think of is the bac...

Read more

Safe Collections is a trading style of Safe Collections Ltd. Registered Office: Centurion House, Centurion Way, Leyland, Lancashire. PR25 3GR Registered in England Company Number 1815264. Consumer Credit Licence 0568305